When Being Wrong Can Be a Blessing

If anyone thinks they know something, they do not yet know as they ought to know. (1 Corinthians 8:2)

Have you ever been completely certain about something, only to realise later that you were wrong? I have. Many times. Sometimes I have even had to apologise for it publicly to my readers. The experience has been humbling—but humility can grow out of humiliation.

Over the years, I have had to revise many of my earlier views and conclusions, particularly in my interpretations of biblical prophecy. Some interpretations that once seemed convincing turned out to be mistaken, and I had to reassess the reasons behind them. But I have begun to think that these mistakes may also have been a blessing to me. Why? Because they have taught me something very important: being convinced of something does not mean that I am right.

That sounds obvious. But how many of us have truly taken it to heart? It is easy to admit, in general, that we are fallible human beings. It is much harder to accept that I might be wrong about the very thing I currently feel most certain about. And I think this is where one of the greatest blessings of being wrong lies.

Once or twice, we may discover how sincerely and confidently we believed something that later proved false. That experience may teach us to approach our present beliefs with a little more humility. We do not necessarily stop believing them, and we do not lose our interest in seeking the truth. But we learn to distinguish between two things: the truth and our feeling of certainty. They are not the same.

This applies to far more than eschatology. It applies to politics, history, science, philosophy—in fact, to every area of life in which we form ideas about the reality around us. The problem is not that people hold strong convictions. I have many of them myself. The problem begins when we treat our own certainty as proof that we are right. Then we may no longer be seeking the truth; we are seeking confirmation for what we have already decided is true. And people who disagree with us begin to look more like enemies than potential conversation partners from whom we might learn something.

Paul’s words in First Corinthians are especially apt here:

If anyone thinks they know something, they do not yet know as they ought to know.

In that chapter, Paul is discussing knowledge that can make a person proud, whereas love builds up. I think this is an important reminder for us as Christians, too. We may know the biblical languages, church history, theology and prophecy. We may read hundreds of books and spend years studying a question. But none of that makes us infallible. Nor does knowledge itself make us wiser if it leads us to treat others arrogantly.

Genuine intellectual humility does not mean that we must avoid strong convictions. It means that we are willing to reassess them when we find sufficient reason to do so. Nor does it mean that all opinions are equally right or that truth is relative. On the contrary: precisely because I believe objective truth exists, I must accept the possibility that my own ideas do not always correspond to it.

Perhaps God can sometimes use our failures to teach us things our successes could never have taught us. If I had always been right, I might be far more dogmatic today. But would I also be wiser? Not necessarily.

Wisdom does not mean never being wrong. It also means learning from our mistakes—and no longer treating our own certainty as proof of the truth. Perhaps, in that sense, some of the greatest mistakes of my life have also been some of my greatest blessings.

This text was written with the help of AI.


Leave a Reply